Doug's Darkworld

War, Science, and Philosophy in a Fractured World.

Friendly Fire

with 6 comments

I’ve given the comments about my last post a lot of thought. I mean, when long time readers disagree with me, at the very least I should consider carefully the wisdom of their words. It’s times like these where I almost regret not being a fundamentalist or a Neocon Republican, it must be nice in a way to have a philosophy that answers all questions and all critics with the same well rehearsed rote answers. However, for good or for ill I rejected all isms as a young man and have never looked back, the universe is way too complicated for any set of beliefs to explain everything and answer all critics. Aside from the basic logic in this, the facts speak for themselves. The greatest atrocities in history are almost always inspired by rote application of some belief.

However, I digress. In the matter at hand, I have decided I won’t be writing any more posts critical of Obama. I mean, Obama supporters and I pretty much agree that McCain is a catastrophically bad choice for president. So for me to criticize Obama would pretty much be considered friendly fire by Obama supporters, in fact almost by definition it is friendly fire. So I’ll find other subjects to direct my criticism at, it’s not like there’s a shortage. It’s just such a damn shame that politics in America has degenerated to the point where people’s votes are often determined by which candidate they despise the least, instead of having candidates with genuine differences of opinion on the issues. So good luck to Obama and his supporters, I can’t give the man a ringing endorsement, but I’ll try to stay out of the way so to speak.

Moving right along, someone took fault with my description of America as “The greatest empire the world has ever seen.” Well, technically speaking, maybe they are correct. However, in many many respects America occupies an almost unparallelled position in history. Since 1945 no fleet or combination of fleets could dispute America’s domination of the world’s oceans, a status that only England (arguably) matched in history. There’s never been a nation that spent as much money on defence as the rest of the world combined. At one point the USA with 6% of the world’s population was consuming over 60% of the world’s resources. That’s probably come down a bit in the last few decades, nonetheless no other nation has ever consumed anywhere near the percentage of the globe’s resources as America. America’s system of global alliances and military bases is again virtually unmatched in history, and certainly unmatched in the current day. I suppose I could say that the USA is a nation of unparallelled economic, political, and military power with a global influence and interests that know no boundaries. However, calling the US the greatest empire the world has ever seen has more cachet, is shorter, and hopefully people can understand that I don’t mean it in a literal sense. And it certainly is an accurate way to describe how most Americans feel about the superiority of their way of life.

A reader suggests that Europe is waiting for the USA to re-engage with the world, not pull out. Well, mea culpa, I suppose that is true, at least in regards to Europe. I wasn’t really including Europe when I made my statement, but I can only agree. Before the Bush administration successive American administrations did try to work with Europe, then along came Bush with his unilateral “you’re with us or against us” style of diplomacy. So I stand corrected on that front, my only comment being, I hope Europe isn’t holding its breath. As for the remark that most in Europe support NATO’s presence in Afghanistan, I’m saddened, but not surprised. Europe invented modern global colonialism, and at heart many in Europe must still have an arrogant paternalistic view of the rest of the world. Maybe not as arrogant and paternalistic as the typical American’s attitude, but it’s there under the surface no doubt. Otherwise their troops in Afghanistan would not enjoy the support of many Europeans.

And lastly, if anyone took offence at my last post, none was meant. And if any was taken, please accept my apologies. (Clearly I have no future as a right wing radio entertainer.) As with all my posts I meant to inspire thought and discussion, not insult people. Sometimes I go over the line, and in this case I clearly did. However, my gentle readers pointed out the error of my ways. If some still disagree with me after my clarifications here, so be it, I know damn well that I don’t have all the answers and that intelligent people can disagree without without either party being in the wrong. I hope.

As always, thanks for the thoughtful comments. Tomorrow, as promised, how to survive a nuclear attack using only your wits and a pillowcase.

(The above image of the aftermath of a friendly fire incident is claimed as Fair Use under US copyright law. It is not being used for profit and arguably it is a historically important image. Crdit and copyright: BBC news. It’s from an incident in 2003 where a US Navy jet mistakenly bombed a group of US and Kurdish soldiers and a BBC news team. In modern warfare, IE since gunpowder came into wide use, friendly fire has typically accounted for about 5-10% of the casualties in war. Yet one more difference between Hollywood’s portrayal of war and the ugly reality.)

Written by unitedcats

July 31, 2008 at 7:30 am

Posted in Politics, World

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. If you’re not offending somebody, you’re not doing the job right.

    Ric

    July 31, 2008 at 12:50 pm

  2. I’m offended by you apologizing in this post!

    Oh come on, you knew someone was going to say it and yes should have known it would be me.

    Steve

    July 31, 2008 at 1:11 pm

  3. Don’t ever apologize for what you believe. You don’t have to be nice and say you’re sorry to get hits just be interesting and topical and never back down. This is your site so write what you think is true and never apologize for it. Being interesting is the most important thing and being a bit controversial never hurt any other of the popular writers, bloggers or tv personalities. If you state a fact wrong you can note it and give the correct fact, if it’s your opinion don’t give in to these weenies! It’s your opinion, stick with it, and never apologize……

    Love the site by the way! Best out there by far!

    Tim D

    July 31, 2008 at 1:17 pm

  4. Ah, politics. I will maintain to my dying breath that all politicians are lying, thieving, conniving scumbuckets, and it’s only a matter of which lying, thieving, conniving scumbucket is going to stay out of my uterus, keep my air clean, do something about the health care mess, and educate the next generation. That would usually be a Democrat.

    Terri

    July 31, 2008 at 3:23 pm

  5. I for one am anxious to read your next post… been having a sense of impending doom lately. although a friend of mine once made a good point, “are you really WANT to survive the apocalypse? it would certainly smell pretty bad.”

    Andrew

    July 31, 2008 at 3:34 pm

  6. As a reader of about a year and decidedly right of most anyone else in these here parts let me say the following.
    No apology was needed and further in that vein I’d echo Ric’s comment. If anyone actually fully read your post they could clearly come away with disagreements but, offense ? Your Oreo comment was actually very polite and illustrative of political positions. This is an issue Obama grapples with in front of and because of both the black and white community.
    I dare say it is unfortunate that you are willing to put your honor on the table and say you won’t be critical of Obama in the future. I hope that doesn’t come back to hurt you, for one’s honor is more important than either of the two potential residents of 1600 Penn.

    Alfie

    August 4, 2008 at 7:33 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: