Doug's Darkworld

War, Science, and Philosophy in a Fractured World.

Gaza Remembered

with 8 comments

gaza_sunset

Well, honestly, I have been pretty unimpressed by the arguments people have presented justifying Israel’s “Operation Cast Lead” in the Gaza Strip. And the more I look into the history of the region and the history of the current “war,” the more unimpressed I am. Most if not all of them seem to be predicated on the idea that Muslims/Arabs are somehow less than human. The “Muslim/Arab=Terrorist/Sub-human” line has been repeated by so many voices over the last few decades that for all practical purposes many in the west and Israel think it’s a statement of fact.

And once one has that as a base to work from, it’s really easy to convince people of all sorts of other nonsense. It makes it easy to blame all the violence on the Muslims/Arabs…and to ignore or even justify Israel’s appalling history of violence. It makes it easy to convince people of things like “they use their own children as human shields.” I mean, to actually believe that human beings would do something like that as a standard practise with widespread support of their friends and families defies all logic, Israelis and Americans who support Israel’s wars would never believe such claims if they were made about Israelis or Americans…but since they already know that Muslims/Arabs are sub-humans who don’t value human life…it’s easy to believe it about them. See how slick and insidious this is? For the record, both sides have a well documented history of using human shields to achieve their ends at times. Welcome to modern war, except of course war has always been this way.

Moving right along, let’s look at how this current round of “fighting” started. On June 19 last year Hamas and Israel signed a cease-fire. Hamas was to stop its rocket attacks and refrain from attacks in Israel, Israel was to relieve the crippling blockade of supplies going into Gaza and refrain from attacks in Gaza. Guess what happened? For four months the rocket attacks essentially stopped, dropping from hundreds a month to a handful a month. And the few that were launched were fired by splinter groups, not Hamas. This is more than a 98% reduction in attacks, combined with the fact that Hamas loudly encouraged Palestinians not to attack Israel, it sure sounds like a good faith effort to stop the rocket attacks. I mean, if the goal was to stop the rocket attacks, seems like a 98% reduction is a good start, nu?

So Israel lifted the blockade? No. They allowed the supplies going into Gaza to increase from 50 tons a day to 70 tons a day. Sounds generous until one knows that prior to the Israeli blockade of Gaza 500-600 tons of supplies a day flowed in. This was, at best, a token gesture on Israel’s part, and very quickly put Hamas under tremendous pressure to resume the attacks. Israel also continued a propaganda war against Hamas and accused them of violating the cease fire in other ways, all without providing any evidence. And Israel launched attacks in the West Bank, while not technically a violation of the cease fire, it clearly wasn’t helping the situation.

Then the fun begins. On November 4 2008, while the world was watching a certain election in a certain important western nation…Israel launched a military attack inside of Gaza, killing six Hamas militants under the claim that Israel was intercepting weapons being smuggled into Gaza. Gee ,what an incredible coincidence that this took place on a  day guaranteed not to be noticed in the western media? Hamas announced that this premeditated attack and the failure of Israel to lift the blockade meant that Israel was in substantial violation of the cease-fire agreement…and the rocket attacks resumed. Even then as the violence escalated Hamas offered to resume the cease-fire under the original terms, but Israel rejected all offers until on December 19 Hamas formally said they would no longer abide by the cease-fire. And on December 27th Israel launched their now bloody  ongoing operation in Gaza. An operation that was in the planning and preparation stages long before the cease-fire was even signed mind you.

I’m sorry, but a 98% reduction in attacks through diplomacy puts the lie to any claim that this military operation is about “stopping the attacks.” And the facts and the time line put to lie the claim that it was Hamas that started this round of fighting, or that Israel had “no other options.” If a 98% reduction in rockets wasn’t a really good start to a diplomatically achieved peace, I don’t know what is. It’s a safe bet that invading Gaza isn’t going to acheive better results.

What a bloody mess. I’d say I don’t know how it’s going to end, except I’d be lying. This is Israel’s seventh try at achieving peace and security by waging war on a neighbour or in the occupied territories since 1973, the last time Israel was actually attacked and forced into war. Of the previous six operations, only two even partially achieved their stated objectives, and all of them decreased Israel’s security in tangible ways. The Israeli invasions of Lebanon radicalized the Muslim population of Lebanon and directly inspired the creation of Hezbollah for God’s sake. If that alone isn’t proof that the idea of achieving peace through war is really stupid, I don’t know what is. And I can safely say that this seventh attempt to acheive peace and security for Israel by waging war on non-Israelis will not make Israel any more secure, and will make Israel less secure in unpredictable and unpleasant ways.

The blitzkrieg, or “shock and awe” as its current proponents call it, ceased to work in about 1942. With few exceptions it has achieved nothing since then, and it’s never succeeded in pacifying an occupied population. In fact in some ways this has played into Hamas’s hands, they now have every incentive to fight to the last man, what have they got to lose? Whether the Israelis kills their women and children through starvation or war, the result is the same. They might as well go out fighting, as would almost anyone in the same circumstances.

(The above image is claimed as Fair Use under US copyright law. Credit: Raising Yousuf. Another view of Gaza, and another of my endless efforts to remind people, including myself, to try looking at things from different perspectives.)

Written by unitedcats

January 14, 2009 at 9:30 am

Posted in History, Propaganda, War, World

Tagged with , ,

8 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Sounds very one-sided. Yes, you are proving your point. But how is that useful and informative?

    psycho

    January 15, 2009 at 1:51 am

  2. Wait… let me get this straight…
    Israel provides supplies to Gaza. And instead of 50 tons a day, they now provide 70 tons a day, which is very kind. But, because that is not as much stuff as they used to give some time ago, Hamas is under tremendous pressure to attack Israel?

    I’m sorry, but that totally defies all logic?

    Nobody has to provide supplies to Gaza. When somebody does it, that’s nice, but it’s not an obligation. So Israel is kind enough to do so. But to say that if they don’t provide enough, Hamas has the right to attack Israel, that is basically stating that Hamas has the right to keep Israel hostage, and blackmail them, just because they’re greedy bastards. That is so utterly wrong.

    And then the 98% thing. It is incorrect to state 98% equals ‘the attacks on Israel have stopped’. Simply put: the attacks did not stop. And in a period of 4 months time, Hamas failed to stop them. From the moment the cease fire started, the attacks went down by 98% almost instantly. So why can’t they stop the other 2% in the next 4 months of time? How difficult is it to order your own people to stop?
    And 2% is still a lot of rockets. And every rocket is one too many. Every country is entitled to defend itself against attacks. And since Israel still got attacked every single day, they’re in their full right to blow the living shit out of Gaza.

    True, some of the rockets could be from splinter cells. And yes, the human shields are ofcourse not Hamas people, but splintercell people forcibly put their by the hand of Hamas. Simply because their is a civil war going on in Gaza as well. Hamas is oppressing a whole number splinter cells and other ‘political’ parties in Gaza. They’re fighting each other in the streets. And that is in my opinion also a valid enough reason for Israel to enter the area.

    Steffen M. Boelaars

    January 15, 2009 at 2:30 am

  3. Steffen,
    Gush Shalom adressed your first point, back in 2007:

    With our own hands we are uniting a million and half people against us, in bitterness and hatred” says Gush Shalom (Israeli Peace Bloc). “The inhabitants of the Gaza Strip are completely dependent on Israel for their most basic livelihood. This complete dependence was created, consciously and deliberately, by all governments of Israel since 1967. The state of Israel cannot now just shrug off its responsibility for the fate of the inhabitants of Gaza. The people of the Gaza Strip have already been living for a long time in terrible squalor, on the very edge of starvation. Now we push them even much deeper into hell. The state of Israel is today roughly trampling International Law, in indiscriminate collective punishments of a whole civilian population.

    As for the ceasefire, the BBC has a graph of goods into Gaza. Notice that October is less than July — inspite of the fact that fewer rockets were fired during October compared to July. Many of the rockets were fired by the al-aqsa Martyrs brigade — Fatah’s armed wing. Hamas arrested an al-Aqsa rocket squad in July 2008.

    Lister

    January 15, 2009 at 12:45 pm

  4. Steffen,

    The innocent people, civilians, women and children are NOT ALLOWED to leave. They have nowhere to run. The UN buildings that they seek refuge in are being blown apart by Israeli bombs. What you do you not get about this? You really think all those civilians deserve to die? You really think that killing family members and children is going to diminish anti-Israeli sentiment? Are you suggesting the extermination of an entire race of people? Sounds like a pretty similar line of reasoning to some of the worst monsters in the history of humanity.

    http://www.alternet.org/audits/120197/gaza_is_a_concentration_camp__/

    Andrew

    January 16, 2009 at 9:42 am

  5. Well, they’re not allowed to leave rightnow, because it’s wartime. But this strugle has been going on for a long time there. It’s not like it’s anything new. It’s like groundhog day! Only without a happy ending. So they’ve had literally a lifetime to go and not live there. They choose this life, they suffer, tough luck. That also immediately nullifies Gush Shalom’s socialist statement. Socialists are surrealists anyway.

    There was a funny cartoon about this in the local paper today: a monkey with the name ‘Hamas’ on its back was sitting in front of a lever, and there was a big arrow pointing to the lever stating “launch missiles!” But in reality when you pulled the lever the monkey would be hit on the head with a really big hammer. Yet it kept on pulling the lever over and over again.

    Steffen M. Boelaars

    January 16, 2009 at 2:25 pm

  6. Wow. You need help.

    Andrew

    January 16, 2009 at 6:00 pm

  7. Name calling is the first and last refuge of those who can’t construct a logical argument. As for someone who finds amusement in the deaths of women and children…that speaks for itself.

    unitedcats

    January 16, 2009 at 6:27 pm

  8. Steffen is a Sociopath in the classic sense.

    “Well, they’re not allowed to leave rightnow, because it’s wartime. ”

    WTF? You think its appropriate to shoot civilians like a fish in a barrel?..

    Israel is suffering from a Sociopathic government and their recent actions will result in several more generations of this mess.

    Eventually the US will not be able to fund the crazy Israeli government, as the USA is broke and the world economy is sliding into a global depression. It is time for any aid to the rouge state to stop and let them support themselves… they would not make it on their own. Too bad moderates are not in control over there..

    Zionism == Nazism

    ET

    January 17, 2009 at 8:11 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: