February 28, 2008...9:57 am

The Dyatlov Pass Accident

Jump to Comments

dyatlov.jpg

Creepiness warning. This is about the Dyatlov Pass Accident, the mysterious deaths of nine young skiers in Russia in 1959. I’d never heard of this until recently, but it was big news in Russia at the time. Then it was covered up, possibly by the KGB, and more or less forgotten about until the collapse of the Soviet Union. That brought out new records and new witnesses, but by no means solved the case. What happened to the nine skiers that long past dark February on the slopes of Kholat-Syakhl mountain?

The basics of the story are simple. Nine experienced cross country skiers went out on a two week cross country ski trek. Actually eight men and two women set out, one of the men got sick and left the trek very early. They set out January 27th 1959. After a few days travel they got delayed or sidetracked by bad weather crossing Dyatlov pass, and set up camp on the slopes of Kholat-Syakhl mountain. This much was reconstructed at the scene and by reading their diaries and developing film found in their cameras (shades of Blair Witch!)

And that was that. They were supposed to return no later than February 12th. When they didn’t return on time, it took awhile to get a search underway. (Being a few days late was normal for a trek like that.) However, as the time went by and there was no sign of them, the search got more and more serious. On February 26th, nearly a month after their departure, their abandoned camp was found. What had happened? They had cut or torn their way out of the tents, and run downhill toward a wooded area some 1.5 kilometres away. They were wearing few if any clothes, and all of them apparently died of hypothermia. What in the name of God would make experienced winter campers flee their tents almost naked and die in the 25-30 C below zero weather?

It gets weirder. While six of them died of hypothermia, three of them had crushing injuries consistent with being struck by a car. One of them was missing her tongue. None of their belongings were gone, and there was no evidence that anyone else had been at the scene. Those are the basic facts. It’s also alleged that Russian military helicopter crews refused to transport the bodies, and that a civilian helicopter was eventually hired by the families for that purpose. Some of the bodies may have been radioactive, and some family members reported the victim’s skin was orange or burned and that all of their hair had turned grey. A group camping to the south of them reported seeing strange orange spheres in the sky over the doomed group the night they died.

And as previously mentioned, the government clamped down on all discussion of the accident. The formal inquest concluded that they had fled their tents because of some “unknown compelling force” and died of hypothermia. All of them fled their tents, the three injured ones were injured after they had fled. The injuries were so severe it was concluded they could not have been inflicted by human beings.

What the hell? I mean, this isn’t some Twilight Zone episode…this really happened. There are a lot of theories, none very convincing. Some have suggested that other humans were involved: local tribesmen, security troops for a secret installation, escaped convicts from a gulag. The local tribesmen are basically pretty mellow, there was no evidence of other people, and all of their possessions were intact. Some sort of secret weapon testing? Normally stuff like that is tested in secure military areas, not out in public. And there’s no evidence of any sort of weapons testing.

An avalanche made them panic and run out in the night? Some sort of weird ultrasound effect drove them into a frenzy? A botched alien abduction? What do you think? I have an idea, but here are more details if the reader wants to come to their own conclusion before reading my brilliant analysis. For a quick overview of the case check out this SF Chronicle article. For a more detailed overview and some pictures, read this article from the MoscowTimes.com. And as always, there’s a wikipedia article.

dyatlov_grave.jpg

I think this can be explained as a case of hypothermia and paradoxical undressing. Basically when people start to die from hypothermia, their brains don’t work right, and they do weird things like get undressed even though it is deadly cold. They had the poor judgement to camp on the windswept side of a mountain in ferocious weather. This was 1959 remember, they may have been well equipped for the time, but basically camping in the open during sub zero weather meant that the wind and cold sucked the heat right out of their bones. And while these were experienced trekkers, they were also college students and may not have had the wisdom of older trekkers. Why did they camp on the mountainside when they could have hiked 1.5 kilometres down into the shelter of the woods? The overconfidence of youth? Possibly the beginning stages of hypothermia were setting in and their judgement was already impaired?

This explains the panicked flight and undressing. Running around in the dark half crazed and running into rocks etc could explain the injuries. A scavenger could explain the missing tongue. Typical Soviet paranoia could explain the secrecy. Details about radioactivity, burned skin, grey hair, and orange spheres aren’t necessarily true. They don’t seem to appear in the original inquest. And remember, the scene wasn’t found until weeks after the deaths, plenty of time for the elements to obscure details and make it look more mysterious than it was. And I can see why the families would want to search for some other explanation, who would want to believe their kids did something really dumb and died naked in the snow as a result? I’m sure more than one group of people has frozen to death in Russia, these things happen.

Still, whatever happened to these lost kids, a sad and curious case. They’d likely be old folks with families and lives today, instead of a few old snapshots posted in the backwaters of the Internet.

(The above images are claimed as Fair Use under US copyright law. They are not being used for profit and are central to illustrating the post. They are arguably historically important images. The top is a picture of Yury Yudin, the soul survivor, hugging Lyudmila Dubinina as he leaves the group. Igor Dyatlov, the group’s leader, watches. This picture was recovered from film found at the death site. The second picture is of their grave site. God rest their souls.)

9 Comments

  • Never heard of this before. Fascinating! That’s why I love this site. It peaks my interest every day.

  • Fascinating. Never heard about this before. Thanks for writing about it.

    Your theory of what happened makes sense. But, it doesn’t explain the tongue. I read the Wikipedia article also, BTW.

    Was victim Dubunina’s - the one whose tongue was missing - mouth open? If not, how did the scavenging beasts take it off? Why didn’t they target the bodies of other victims or even, other body parts of Dubunina?

    The rest of your theory makes sense - especially since 2 of the campers tried to make a fire & a few others tried to return to the camp.

  • Ok. Um, sometimes the tongue protrudes after death. It’s not unusual for scavenging animals to grab it, among other protruding parts. I’ll post about the so called “cattle mutilation” cases some days, my research into that showed that nasty things happen to bodies in the wilderness settings. As for why only the tongue of one victim, I dunno, something scared the predator off? I don’t claim that maybe something else may have happened, just that hypothermia and attendant madness is a plausible theory.

    Too bad this was 1959, modern forensic science could have made more of the case. Be interesting to see what a good profiler would say though, I think?

  • Interesting bit about the tongue - Makes perfect sense. Yes, we must understand that forensic science must have been primitive then.

    Not to mention the rocks some people found in the vicinity - some people had fractures, maybe because they fell & hit the rocks. Someone used “getting hit by a car” as a metaphor & that stuck. Dubunina may have fallen on a rock & bit her tongue hard. Such things happen.

    People are always seeing “orange spheres” - I saw several once when I was a kid. Only to read the next day about night-time test flights that the Indian Airforce conducted. I couldn’t convince my schoolmates that the spheres were not UFOs, though. People love mysteries & they just hated me for deflating their “belief”.

  • Excuse. I am well familiar with this history. I can tell the following. It is not necessary to put accent on that that there was no only the tongue. It ours in 3 months after death. The snow already thew. Has been found in water. In documents on medical research it is written that there was all person is damaged almost and not just there was no the tongue. This natural condition in such conditions. The attention to the tongue was turned only by journalists and writers of books about this case. They have not told that in documents was exact. Writers very much love sensations

    About “orange spheres” the following is possible to tell. It is the optical phenomenon at start of a space rocket it was far from this place. Started a rocket on distance about 2000 kms.-1500 miles.

    It is very guilty badly I state in English. Itself I live in Russia. All documents read in Russian in the original..

  • I like your explanation. Has the benefit of parsimony.

  • I think an avalanche would be the most reasonable explanation for this.
    1. it would explain the violent injuries to their bodies and organs
    2. an avalanche could easily tear bodies out of nylon tents
    3. the radiation could be “dirty” snow that had fallen prior to the avalanche, or even contaminated them after they died
    4. dirty bolcheviks, haha

  • [...] the same spirit as my column on the Dyatlov Pass Accident I thought I’d cover another historical disaster mystery, the 1975 London Moorgate tube crash. [...]

  • I think that maybe theywere doing something with a radio and something wet wrong with some stuff they were messinging around with and a blast of some sort went off and it burned them(The orange skin and grey hair and it also says that they could of been blind) So they ran out of the tent not knowing where they were going. Thats what I think.

Leave a Reply